QUADIFYRC MODS AND REVIEWS
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact

QUADIFYRC Quadcopter reviews

TP3 ultralight 3" micro quad build and review: Lockdown edition

3/5/2020

4 Comments

 
The "toothpick" series of ultra lightweight quad was made popular by Bob Roogi (Kabab FPV). all original parts can be found on his site here: https://fpvcycle.com/ After enjoying the original 65mm toothpick builds I was very excited to build a  larger, more powerful 3 inch "TP3" version but I've never been able to buy all the parts owing to the popularity.

So I've decided to spec my own TP3 build inspired by his specifications. Since this quad is essenially a sum of components I will do breakout reviews linked in this master review which ties it all together,
Picture
Here are the parts I've chosen
Frame - ZJWRC 115X
This frame has a truly unforgettable name and a waste of time canopy but the baseplate is TOUGH and the hardware is actually useful. At $14 the price is ok and it is always in stock. See more details in my frame review here. Premium alternatives include the original TP3, racer-x twig, and more but for me if a frame does the basics well I don't bother with something expensive. I'm pleased to say this frame does do the basics well. If you are looking for something cheaper and lighter consider the Eachine Twig frame at $8 but personally I prefer the stiffness of the ZJWRC 115x frame I used here.
Picture
ZJWRC 115x frame at Banggood
Picture
Racer-x twig
Picture
TP3

Read More
4 Comments

ZJWRC 115x 3 inch tootpick frame review

17/10/2019

2 Comments

 
Picture
Ever since the HQ3x2 t-mount prop and the more powerful nameless RC 412T FC/ESC board was released I've wanted to build a 3 inch ultra-light 'toothpick' style quad. Since then Speed Racer released the 3" Twig and Kabab has released the TP3. International shipping on these can be a killer though so when there was a frame released on Banggood I opted to give it a try.
Picture
The frame I'm reviewing today is the ZJWRC 115x which is available here from Banggood. I haven't heard of the brand before either! The kit I reveived included:
  • 3" wheelbase 3mm thick carbon fibre base plate
  • TPU canopy
  • 4 x m2x20mm steel scres with thread standoffs for mounting board and nuts for fixing canopy.
  • Carppy yellow battery strap
Let's take a closer look at the components:

Read More
2 Comments

HOBBYMATE ASTEROID 3 INCH QUADCOPTER: Review

9/5/2019

2 Comments

 
Picture
The Hobbymate Asteroid is a new 3 inch quadcopter that is available in kit, BNF or PNF formats that is available with motors and electronics suitable for 4s or 6s (!) operation. Following on from the awesome Hobbymate Comet (built here and reviewed here) this is another premium set of components at a spectacular price. It is available exclusively from HobbyCool.com here:
​​
http://hobbycool.com/asteroid-3-mini-fpv-racing-drone-kit/

In part 1 of this blog here I looked at the build and betaflight setup process in full. In this part 2 I'm taking a closer look at the components and review in general.
On the bench
From a specs standpoint this is a pretty special kit but that only tells half the story. I'll walk through the components and talk about their strong and or weak points
Picture
Hobbymate 1505 motors made by RCInpower. These are the stars for me. Like other modern RCInpower motors they are beautifully made: the single piece machined bell, the strong magnets with retention ring with an impossibly small air gap and the multistranded windings. Just as interesting is the size choice. 1505 is a wider stator but much shorter than usual. As a result it should have more turning force (torque) but potentially less top end and better efficiency as a result. Although it sounds like a large number the stator volume is not actually that big - see my comparison table below for some suprising comparisons.
1108
1306
1407
1408
1505
1506
1606
760
796
1077
1231
883
1060
1206
Comparison of common 3" motor stator volumes in cm^3
​Motors are available in 4300kV for 4s and 2700kV for 6s. Mine are 4300kV which I feel are a little high for 4s but more on that later.
iFlight SucceX F4. This is a pretty special unit from a specification standpoint, the most compact powerful flight stack to date:
  • 35A BLHeli_32 ESC
  • F4 flight control with 3 UARTS
  • 25/100/200mW VTX
Like most modern iflight products it is nicely made and presented.
Picture

Read More
2 Comments

Hobbymate Asteroid 3 inch quadcopter: Build Tutorial and betaflight pids etc.

29/4/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
The Hobbymate Asteroid is a new 3 inch quadcopter that is available in kit, BNF or PNF formats that is available with motors and electronics suitable for 4s or 6s (!) operation. Following on from the awesome Hobbymate Comet (built here and reviewed here) this is another premium set of components at a spectacular price. It is available exclusively from HobbyCool.com here:

http://hobbycool.com/asteroid-3-mini-fpv-racing-drone-kit/
The purpose of this blog is to show how I have built in close detail and how I have set up betaflight software for optimal performance. Note you can spend an extra $30 to have this build with a FRSKY receiver but I always like to tinker and optimise my build which is why I have chosen this path. Update: review now completed here
I like to take my time on a build and ensure I have a clean well lit area. Makes things easier when I inevitably drop screws or small parts on the floor. My recommended list of budget tools is here.
Picture
1. Overview of all the parts. Components are outstanding, I will cover this more in part 2 (the review)
Picture
2. Closer look at the motors. These are more beautiful in real life with a 1 piece bell
Picture
3. This Iflight stack is compact, well desined and capable of up to 6s!
Picture
4. Lightweight Caddx EOS2 cam. This is the 4:3 version which gives a much better FOV than the 16:9 version as found on the trashcan

Read More
0 Comments

Eachine Tyro79: Build tips, Setup and Review

1/3/2019

18 Comments

 
Picture
The Eachine Tyro79 is the second in Eachine's Tyro series, the first being the budget Tyro99 5 inch quadcopter kit. The most astonishing thing about this quadcopter kit is it's price - it is only $79 for a 3" kit. Clearly there have been areas where Eachine have cut costs but they've made a suprisingly good quad given those compromises.

Read More
18 Comments

3 inch T-mount Propeller Comparison

24/9/2018

1 Comment

 
Picture
T-mount propellers are those that are based on a 1.5mm diameter centre shaft secured by a 2mm screw either side. They have been the only mounting option for 2-2.5 inch props but are now becoming more popular for 3" due to the weight they save over a 5mm single shaft prop mount. There are only 4 different types of t-mount 3" prop currently available so I've compared them all plus the new HQ 2 blade which is due for imminent release plus a darkhorse prop in a smaller size to make up the numbers. Please note this is a subjective comparison based on my opinion but my help as a startpoint for your decision. This is based on real world feel, light time and bitter experience with motors I've burnt out.
Picture
Emax Avan 3 inch tri-blade
This is the first modern design 3 inch prop designed for a t-mount which was released with the 3" Babyhawk R (reviewed here).
  • Weight and Response: 1.27g This is very light for  tri-blade and mass is concentrated near the hub meaning response is very good for a triblade of this pitch.
  • Pitch: Mid-range. This is well suited to 3s on an 1106 4500kV and will manage a 4s as well but is reasonably amp-hungry. Make sure your motors are not hot.
  • Balance: Very good, typical of modern tri-blade
  • Durability: Low-medium. Less material on the outer part of the blades means they bend/break easily, especially towards the edge of the blade
  • Other notes: warning: given the unique design of the blade near the hub, this is unlikely to fit any motor with a stator size larger than 11mm. Update: confirmed these fit successfully without modification on the RCX 1304. New RCX 1306 unconfirmed.
  • Recommendations: Excellent on 3s but be cautious on 4s considering this is limited to 13mm stator size
  • Available from: Banggood, Hobbycool

Picture
Unique blade design close to hub means 11mm stator (maybe 12mm) is maximum
Picture
HQ 3x3x3 v1s tri-blade
HQ props have the newest 3" t-mount prop design at present. This has been chosen as the stock propeller for the Full Speed Leader 3 (initial review here and flights here)
  • Weight and Response: 1.49g Traditional blade design meaning response is in-line with weight: slow (in this class)
  • Pitch: Agressive. On an 1106 4500kV motor with 3s this is amp hungry and with 4s it consistently burns out motors (as I found here with the Leader 3) Should suit the larger stators like the hypetrain brat 1407 well.
  • Balance: Excellent, typical of modern tri-blade
  • Durability: Medium-high. Ever since the launch of the original 5x4.3x3 v1s, HQ have really got their prop material sorted.
  • Other notes: I believe this agressive pitch is the reason behind the premature deaths of the original Leader 3 release. I'd recommend against using these on 4s for 1106 and below.
  • Available from: FullSpeedRC, Piroflip

Picture
Gemfan 3035 triblade
This is quite an old prop and can be hard to find but is still suprisingly relevant.
  • Weight and Response: 1.42g This is a midweight prop and response is medium for a tri-blade
  • Pitch: Light. A light pitch means this is a good option for higher kv motors on 3s or 4s on 11mm sized stators. Probably a little light for motors with larger stator sizes.
  • Balance: Good,typical of a tri-blade.
  • Durability: Medium - probably slightly better than the avan.
  • Other notes: This is a good match for 11mm sized stators and some have found that running this prop on the Leader 3 can prevent motor failure on 4s without an appreciable loss in speed compared to the HQ 3x3x3 - probably because it can get this prop to peak speed unlike the HQ. Probably a bit light for larger motors. Can be hard to get hold off but Banggood and HobbyCool seem to have stock for international delivery.
  • Available from: Banggood, Gearbest,Hobbycool

Picture
Gemfan 3025 bi-blade
This is the original 3" t-mount prop and so can be found for sale in weird and wonderful places
  • Weight and Response: 0.97g This is an extremely lightweight prop and reponse is very high as a result.
  • Pitch: Very light. A very light pitch means this is a good option for higher kv motors on 3s or 4s on 11mm sized stators. Probably wasted on anything larger than an 1106 unless you are looking for endurance.
  • Balance: Mediocre. Not intrinsically bad but being a bi-blade means it is prone to become unblanced quicky when damaged
  • Durability: Very poor. Short of landing on a pillow these are easily damaged
  • Other notes: This is a good match for 11mm sized stators that can be guaranteed not to stress your motors. I've even run these on 1103 motors on very lightweight builds. This is a really good match with 4s 1106 like on the leader 3 or babyhawk r but have poor grip when the weight is higher. Best prop available if you are superlight or want super-endurance.
  • Available from: Banggood, Gearbest,Hobbycool

Picture
HQ 3x3x2 v1s bi-blade
Just released at the time of writing: as per the 3x3x3 above but bi-blade rather than triblade. Disclaimer: I have not tested yet and below information based on assumptions from comparing bi-blades and tri-blades in general. Will update once mine arrive and I've tested.
  • Weight and Response: 1.1g (est.) Bi-blade means this is a light prop and should be very responsive
  • Pitch: Agressive. Shoud be less amp hungry than the tri-blade version but would still recommend excercising caution using 4s on an 11mm stator size.
  • Balance: Good however being a bi-blade it is more prone to getting out of balance.
  • Durability: Medium-high: same as the tri-blade
  • Other notes: Although this still has an aggressive pitch, 1 less blade should mean this is less of an amp-hog for a given thrust i.e. it should be efficient at the cost of grip. Consider this for a lighter build or for extended endurance but expect to use more throttle to hold a line on cornering.
  • Available from: RaceDayQuads

Dark horse to consider...
Picture
Gemfan 2540 flash triblade
Yes this is a 2.5" prop but objectively it is so good it is worth considering downsizing. You can find an earlier review I did on these here and a review on the Skystars Bolt X120 which uses these on 4s here
  • Weight and Response: 1.0g This is a very lightweight prop and response is very good - especially if it is on a motor designed for a 3" prop
  • Pitch: Agressive but since the blade length is smaller it won't stress your 11mm stator size motor. Pointless on any motor bigger than that (except perhaps the 1404/1304)
  • Balance: Excellent
  • Durability: Excellent. This is the toughest of the lot
  • Other notes: The standout prop in the 2.5" class punches above it's weight in 3" quads. It's durable and won't stress your motors (even on 4s) but it naturally delivers less maximum thrust and efficient due to it's size. I wish they'd make this same prop extended to 3"....
  • Available from: Banggood, Gearbest,Hobbycool, Piroflip

Others:
Please note the King Kong 2840 propeller was not included here because I found the Gemfan 2540 superior in every way. Also I have not include the Rotor X 3044 because it is difficult to source where I am based. The feedback that I have had is that it is more aggressive in pitch than any of the above props and probably only suitable for for stator sizes 13xx and up.​
1 Comment

FULL SPEED RC LEADER 3 SE REVIEW PART 2: Flight performance on 3s and 4s

6/8/2018

0 Comments

 
If you haven't yet seen the first part of my Leader 3 (SE) review, click here. In it I cover an overview of the New Leader 3 including full discussion of the components, build and software setup. A quick correction too: I mentioned originally that the flight controller (namely the gyro) will only do 8kHz loop times. This is incorrect - it will actually run up to 32kHz! Certainly the first I'm aware of on a board this size and something for me to test in future.
Picture
Before I go any further I should note that my Leader 3 is a review model and so there may be minor improvements in the final version shipped to buyers. I'm in regular contact with Full Speed RC to give them feedback on what I find to assist with these improvements. The Leader 3 is available directly from FullSpeedRC.com, Gearbest or Bangood.

Video performance
Since FPV performance is common between 3s and 4s I thought I'd cover that first. In short it is outstanding. Fullspeed RC shared a lot of the development of the included TX600 vtx with me an a lot of effort went in to ensuring a clean video signal all the way up to 600mW and the results sure doesn't disappoint. The result is that the Leader 3 has the cleanest video signal I have every used. There is absolutely no impact of throttle or other electrical noise on signal and it is hard to put in words just how much more enjoyable this makes the signal. I do miss the audio that AKK VTXs allow for but most people don't rate this as being important, especially on a micro. It's noteworthy that the the transmission power will go as high as 600mW - equalled only by the AKK FX3 ultimate (review here) in this form factor. OSD control of settings via Tramp works as expected. Antenna connection is via UFL is common for micros and fit for purpose.

No propellers in FPV view
Great news for those who don not like seeing their propellers - the frame design means that even with fairly modest camera angles of around 35°and up there are no props in view. Hopefully this is clear from my videos below. This also make the drums for a Caddx Turtles HD camera install beat even louder...

Camera Angle
I wanted to clear things up on camera angle since Nick Burns mentioned it couldn't go past about 45° in his otherwise excellent review. I can confirm that the camera connector does not foul on the flight stack and does infact smoothly go all the way up to about 90° amgle. Pictures are best here so please see below:

Picture
Hats off to you if you fly at this camera angle
Picture
Picture
Performance on 3s
When the Leader 3 was shipped to me, 2 custom PID prodiles were programmed in by fullspeed, Profile 1 was designed for 3s and profile 2 for 4s. 3s was tested with profile 2. Both of these profiles can be seen in full in part 1 of the review here. For 3s testing I used Turnigy Nanotech 3s 450mah 65c batteries. They weigh less than 45g meaning all up weight was around 140g. Flight time using these batteries was typically around 2.5-3 minutes with batteries coming to a resting voltage of arounf 3.75v per cell.

Flying exclusively with the HQ 3x3x3 propellers flight felt very 'balanced' - what I mean by that is the quad didn't feel overly heavy (or light), top speed was fast enough but not ludicrously fast like the Skystars Bolt X120 on 4s (review here). It was however very predictable - I could hit gaps and avoid obstacles in a way where I felt I had complete control. It was fairly similar to the way the Emax Babyhawk R 3 inch felt (review here) but the HQ props felt more predictable and familar compared to the EMAX Avans. This makes sense - both the Leader 3 and Babyhawk R are of similar weight and with 1106 4500kV motors on 3 inch props and both have optimised PID tunes. Full Speed RC seem to have done a good job on the tune here not just for the feel during flying but also in keeping propwash to a minimum, even when I tried to put myself in dirty air in 180° turns or descending directly down.

Below is a video from an early flight (2nd pack ever) in a local carpark. Typical I had DVR issues in a flight later that day where I'd gotten more familiar with the flight characteristics :/
Performance on 4s
The battery I used for all 4s testing was the China Hobbyline Ministar 4s 650mah pack. It is an excellent battery that I even use on my 4 inch racer so is very capable although a little heavy at 87g.

First of all I'm going to talk about straight up speed and my perception. It did not feel as fast as the Skystars Bolt X120 using the same battery. This is not an objective measure, purely feel. It did feel faster than the Babyhawk R 3" using the same battery.

To dig in to this further though I do need to say that that Skystars Bolt X120 is very hard to control with this battery and I did not enjoy flying it because it felt difficult to control. It felt like it needed more open space which then kinda defeats the purpose of a micro. By comparison the Leader 3 felt in complete control using 4s and PID profile 2 as customised for 4s by Full Speed RC. As a result it felt right at home on 4s with all the control and balance I felt on 3s. I think part of this is due to tune but moreso that that larger 3 inch blade is able to better support the additional weight from the heavier pack and hasn't overloaded the propeller (disc loading theory).

All other features of flight were similar to 3s - excellent video, precise handling and minimised propwash. I was really enjoying flying this until...
Disaster Struck!
When I first received this model, Full Speed RC cautioned me to use 4s using the smaller Gemfan 2540 props (review here) since motors could overheat. Since I was the only reviewer to receive mine where it is winter presently rather than summer, this was less of an issue although I did keep an eye on motor temps. For this reason I stuck with the included 3 inch props for 4s.

About 10 packs in of warm motors (40-50°C only) I fell out of the sky when attempting a short speed run (see video below). On closer inspection the left rear corner had failed that I could later confirm as a motor failure (as opposed to ESC). The motor definitely was warm only as above and not hot. The only other time I've had a motor failure was on the babyhawk r when I used PIDs with too much P and D on 4s and even then the motor did not fail mid flight, rather afterwards intsead. This motor was scorching hot.
I discussed this with Full Speed RC and found that they will be using a stronger motor on the production version - the review version like I have are a prototype. As you can see below when comparing to my burnt out motor on the Emax Babyhawk R, the Fullspeed one does not look nearly as abused - it failed at a much lower load. Interestingly shortly after this I saw Andy RC's review and found he had an identical problem - motor failed mid run using 4s with HQ 3x3x3 props. Update: The prototype motors are actually 4800-4900kV and the production version will be 4500kV.
Picture
Coil lamination seem to have failed without excess heat in the fullspeed motors?
Picture
I absolutely cooked these emax motors - came down scorching hot and even then didn't fail mid flight.
So, what does this mean for you? Until I can confirm that Fullspeed RC have moved away from the proptotype motors I can't recommend using the HQ 3x3x3 props with 4s, even in cold weather. For now stick with Gemfan 2540 props on 4s. Of course if it ships with new motors then all bets are off. Full Speed RC is sending me a full set of new motors so I will test with these and post my results in a follow up review as soon as I am able. Update: The prototype motors are actually 4800-4900kV and the production version will be 4500kV.
Conclusion
The  Full Speed RC Leader 3 is as an excellent flyer on 3s - great video signal and predictable handling make for an enjoyable flying experience. On 4s the Jury is out... custom pids make this fly well too but the motors' inability to cope with the included 3" props are a bit disappointing. For now a bandaid solution is to run with Genfan 2540 props on 4s but I expect that Full Speed will release with a stronger motor for launch as they did with the original Leader 120. Again, my sample is a reviewer model and this feedback is used to make changes if needed to the final launch product. Full Speed RC has proven themselves to be a reputable company with well researched (and tested) quadcopters and I expect them to follow through on this model too.
The Leader 3 can be purchased directly from FullSpeedRC.com - their shipping is a little more expensive ($8) but is the fastest. Alternatively you can now purchase at Gearbest (standard version) or Banggood (standard or special edition) or Hobbycool (special edition)
0 Comments

Full Speed RC Leader 3 SE Review Part 1: OVerviewand setup

22/7/2018

7 Comments

 
PictureThe Leader 3 SE from fullspeedrc.com
Introduction
The Leader 3 (SE) is a follow up to the hugely successful Leader 120 which I have reviewed and documented modification extensively, most recently with a summary here. Both are available from Fullspeedrc.com This has been a highly anticipated release not least of which because there has been no releases from Full Speed since last years' Beebee 66 light. The good news is that a big chunk of that wait has been spent working on the Leader 3. FYI two of the main guys are pilots from Full Speed RC are pilots and do a lot of work testing before release which is a welcome change in this hobby compared to many models that come out half-baked.

Firstly the Leader is available in 2 variants. The standard model (Leader 3) can be seen below and weighs 87g with regualar standoffs. The Leader 3 SE is exclusive to Fullspeedrc.com and comes with a 3d printed canopy instead of the standoffs. It is 6g heavier but offers several benefits that I'll cover a little later on.

A run through the components
First the frame. Like the Leader 120 the base plate of the frame is 3mm thick although it has been stretched to 130mm motor to motor diagonally rather than 120mm This means it is capable of accepting a true 3" propeller rather than 2.8" maximum on the Leader 120. The frame is most definitely still a 'deadcat' shape meaning the two motors are further apart (107mm) than the 2 rear motors (98mm). Additionally it is a 'squashed-x' compared to a 'stretched-x' meaning the front and rear motors on the same side are closer together. This means it should be more stable in the roll vs. pitch axis but modern flight software somewhat negates this. Compared to the leader 120, sideplates have increased from 2mm to 3mm thick which should aid durability. More imporatantly a 19mm gap rather than 17-18mm means the leader 3/SE now natively fits a 19mm micro cam. It's worth nothing that the baseplate is only 1 piece so you cannot replace single arms. Personally I think replaceable arms are unnecessary on any quad size less than 4" since there is much less leverage for breaking on a smaller quad. The frame can be purchased separately here.
Picture
107mm wide motor to motor at the front
Picture
98mm wide motor to motor at the back
Picture
130 - 131mm diagonally motor to motor
The canopy (Leader 3SE only). When I first saw the canopy I wasn't keen because it adds 8g weight however I think the functionality may just offset that - jury is out until I fly it some more. The 3d TPU print is of very high quality available in black,white, red, purple, blue or yellow and performs the following functions:
  • Replaces the standoffs
  • Provides strain-relieve for battery wires
  • Provides positive mounting and protection for VTX and receiver antennae
  • Sharkfit provides a fulcrum for flip over after crash (anti turtle) mode.
  • Provides protection for buzzer/LED unit
  • Looks tidy.
Picture
Picture
Picture
The motors are 1106 4500kv which is the same specs as those found on the Emax Babyhawk R 3 inch and the Skystars X120. They are not open bottom and have mounting holes for regular t-mount props and the emax 2.3" avan props. Most importantly they are rated for up to 4s.
Picture
Picture
Picture
The stack is a Fullspeed FSD F428 flight tower. The flight controller has a F411 chip and will run up to 8k gyro loop and so requires little in the way of soft mounting. The BEC onboard is 5v 3A. It looks to have a pad for current sensing which is good news if you are wanting to use this funtional although you'll need to use something like the FSD Amass XT30 Current Sensor since the ESC does not have native current sensing. Speaking of the ESC it is rated to 28A, runs BLHeli_S and most importantly is capable of 2-4s. The stack can be bought separately here.
Picture
Picture
The VTX is a brand new unit that has only just been released by FullSpeed: the FSD TX600. This is a 20mm x 20mm stackable vtx that is switchable between PIT/25mW/100mW/200mW/400mW/600mW. All parameters can be controlled via betaflight/butterflight OSD via the IRC Tramp protocol. I'm looking forward to trying it because the test DVR that I've seen looks to be extremely clear. It can be purchased separately here
The camera used is the Caddx F1 which uses at 1200TVL CCD sensor. I've not used this particular one before and am looking forward to trying it out. FullspeedRC sell the camera here for only $15
Picture
Picture
Propellers included are the HQ 3x3x3 At present fullspeed recommends these on 3s and the 2540 on 4s in summer. I'll be trying the included props on both 3s and 4s since it is winter where I am. Available here
Receiver: I requested a frsky receiver and FullspeedRC included their own model - a d8 based FSD frsky nano V2 which I've reviewed here (although this was the V1 version) The v1 has better range with a proper dipole antenna and broadcasts RSSI over channel 9 by default. This can be bought here - also available in spectrum and flysky flavour.
Picture
The Build
Like the original Leader 120, build quailty is excellent. Solder is clean, wires are cut to length. Not much more to say here, it is well beyond my ability! With the quad assembled there is plenty of room behind the camera to adjust tilt (45° and beyond are capable) and the receiver is mounted in this void. with plenty of room left yet. This is speculation but I'd like to address anyway since it seems like a common thread: my best guess is the caddx turtles HD FPV/DVR (not yet released at time of writing) will fit but not without a little modification. My reasoning is that there seems to be 2-3mm 'spare' room between each stack layer. If these standoffs are trimmed by this amount you will be able to save 6-9mm in height which should be enought to fit the turtles board. It will require some fine wire management and a steady hand to trim the standoff but I do think it may be physically possible - a project for another day. That being said, the double stack of the runcam split micro definitely will not fit.
Picture
Picture
Picture
I think I can get 2-3mm off each layer of standoffs here - enough to make room for a Caddx turtles maybe?
Software setup
Plenty to talk about here although most can be foundin commentary of the Betaflight screens below. If you don't choose to read these however:
  • This flight controller has a unique target that is supported in both betaflight and butterflight: 'FULLSPEEDF411'
  • Ships with Betaflight 3.3.3
  • It is the most customised betaflight I have ever come accross. Custom PIDS for 3s (profile 1), 4s (profile 2), buzzer, OSD, arm angle etc. etc. A lot of thought has gone into this.
  • Hex files for betaflight 3.3.3, 3.4.0, butterflight 3.5.0 are available here
Final thoughts pre-flight
As you can see from above this looks to be a very well thought out quad and not something slapped together from a spare parts bin. The Babyhawk R and Skystars bolt X120 have both shown that 1106 4500kV motors perform well on 4s in 2.5" and 3" so I am excited to see what the Leader 3SE will add here with all the work that has gone into development from a hardware and software perspective. On paper this looks to have the edge on both of those models in terms of weight, VTX capability and ESC current overhead however the real test will come in flight - stay tuned for part 2 of this review where I will cover flight in full - I already have 3s and 4s batteries charged for tomorrow :)
Picture
The Fullspeed RC Leader 3/SE can be bought directly from Fullspeedrc.com and is also available at other retailers however buying from the source is your best chance to get your hands on one quickly.
If you are new to my site check out my reviews or tips and tricks blogs, they are loaded with useful information
7 Comments

EMAX BabyHawk R 136mm 3 INCH micro quad review

12/4/2018

2 Comments

 
PictureThe Emax BabyHawk R 136mm with all the gear I need to fly FPV
The Emax Baby Hawk R is a micro brushless quadcopter that was launched by Emax in early 2018 as a follow up to the highly successful Emax Babyhawk (not r). It was launched as a 2 inch but 2.5 inch aftermarket arms quickly became available in the aftermarket and hugely improved the power to weight ratio, disc loading and efficiency. Emax themselves have now taken this one step further with the Babyhawk R 136mm (3 inch). Compared to the 2 inch version is has the longer arms with the new Avanflow 3 inch 3-blade propellers and a reduction in motor KV from 6000kv down to 4500kv although motor size is still the same 1106. Weight of the 3 inch is 86g compared to 82g. I will review the Babykawk R 136mm (3 inch) here.

Specs and discussion
  • 136mm motor to motors. This is relatively compact for a 3" stretched x frame.
  • Emax Magnum F3 Magnum flight controller with MPU6000 gyro. Will run the latest versions of Betaflight (3.3)/Butterflight (3.4) with pretty much all options available up to about 4k/4k gryo pid loops. F4 would have been nice for better future proofing but F3 is fine for now. The flight controller is nicely softmounted on the frame. Not usually necessary for the MPU6000 gyro but a nice option nonetheless.
  • Emax Magnum 12A BLHeli_S esc. On paper looks weak but the reality is that EMAX have rated this for 4s on the 1106 motors so it is all that is required. There could be an argument for going with BLHeli_32 but probably falls in the same camp as the F3/F4 discussion.
  • Emax RS1106 4500kV motor. Nice torquey kv rating to spin the 3" props. Designed in the good efficiency/power range for 3 or 4s.
  • Foxeer Arrow Micro Camera. Solid branded CCD FPV camera
  • Emax Magnum 25mW / 200mW VTX. Basic VTX with two most common operating frequencies for a micro. No smart Audio is a minor disappointment but cannel change button is easy to access as display LED.
  • Avan 3 inch props. Will comment more on these since the specs alone don't leave us a lot to go with.

On paper none of these components are especially exciting or on the hype-train. A big HOWEVER though - all are very tried and true, solid and well balanced. This means reliability and reduced cost. The each have a job to do and do it without fuss or flair. It's fair to say though that when you bring them together they are greater than the sum of parts.

Quick rambling thoughts how 3 inch quad weights

I think of 3 inch quads in 2 ways - a shrunk down 5" based on large motors and 4s batteries or an embiggened micro based on 11XX series motors and 3s. This clearly fits in the camp of "embiggened micro" since it is based around 1106 motors however it is farily unique in that the ESC, motors as well tough frame and cowling are well and truly engineered for 4s - best of both worlds as it were. By constrast my lightweight FlexRC komori (build blog is here) can take 4s but the frame would not hold up to carrying the extra weight of a 4s. Conversely something like the Furibee X140 (review blog here) is pretty gutless on a 3s where it can't overcome the 120g+ weight of the quad.
Picture
The Flex RC komori is a 72g 3 inch. It is limited to 2 or 4s because of the lightweight frame's ability to take a hit.
Picture
The Furibee X140 is a 125g 3 inch and is by no means heavy for a 3 inch. It can run 3 or 4s but really needs 4s IMO
Picture
The Babyhawk R weighs 86g and is designed for 3s or 4s
Setting up

I haven't delved into all the betaflight screens this time because for the most part this is down to preference and your gear. What I can say though is that although not installed from the factory, EMAX have provided some VERY good PIDS for both 3s and 4s. Here is the link to their page or for convinience please see below:
Picture
3s PIDS. Click to enlarge
Picture
4s PIDS. Click to enlarge
Fly the damned thing

At the time of writing I've only run this on 2s and 3s. 2s was using a 46g 950mah turnigy nanotech battery and was very uninspiring but hey, at least it can be done! 3s was much better than I thought it would be. I used the Turnigy Nanotech 3s 460mah battery (about 42g) and got 2.5 - 3 minutes flight depending on how hard i pushed, coming down at about 3.75v per cell at rest.

The first thing I have to say about the flight is that all of these solid if unspectacular components do come together so nicely - they are all well suited which not only make for an enjoyable and reliable fllight experience but means the cost does not blow out. In addition the protection offered by the 3mm carbon-armed and cowled frame means that even after tumbles there is a good chance you can just rearm and get flying again - it is tough! The other benefit of the cowl is that it looks cool, different from the top plate/bottom plate or side cage frames that are out there.
In the air I think the standard emax 3 inch props props are a real star. They have a pitch that starts of very slight at the tip and gets more and more aggressive with larger blade area the closer you get to the motor. It means that even on 3s with a realtively slow spinning 4500kV motor you can get really good performance. Combine this with the excellent PIDs as above and it has honestly been one of my favourite flying experiences, particularly staying tight and low around trees in parks where I do most of my flying. I do find the blades bend relatively easy but do bend back fairly easy as well. I'm pleased that they are a good prop because there is a realy dearth of 3" propellers with a t-style mount. A quick note that the motors come down barely warm.
Picture
Here you can see the unique design of the prop the emax officially calls: AVAN MINI 3 INCH PROPELLER 3X2.4X3
Punch out power is ok on 3s but will hold my judgement till I get some 4s packs. understandably the light 3s packs make for great agility which is why I had a lot of fun with proximity around the small trees in the park that I have close to work.

For FPV camera performance is good - as to be expected from the foxeer arrow micro CCD. VTX is clear in the right conditions and is better than most other micros however I do undersand this can be improved significantly with an AXII ufl antenna (or the cheaper UXII). Channel and power level is easy to change via the small button but as suggested above there is no smart audio or tramp protocol to do this over betaflight OSD.
Summary

Obviously I haven't tried on 4s yet (I am just choosing a 500-700mah 4s to order), but based on the performance of 3s I think this quad is a real winner.

Emax have done a fantastic job on not getting carried away on needlessly overspeccing the quad in areas you cannot really taking advantage of. In doing so they have a solid, robust and well priced offering that I can see becoming very popular like the babyhawk before it albeit with less shortcomings. Better still the support that emax appear to be offering beyond regular customer service such as offering tuned PIDs means that community support will mean there are always going to be clever fixes and modifications that will be available, making obsolesence for this model is less likely. Make no mistake obsolesence is a real issue with quads because once the community moves away from a model there is less support in total available.

Although experienced builders and customisers will still likely want to build their own, It is very easy to recommend this as a first 'racing' micro quad becuase of it's inherent features and support. As a micro quad builder myself it's hard for me to say but this is actually more enjoyable to fly than most of my custom builds because it all comes together so nicely. For that reason it is easy to recommend this to the more experienced set that just want to fly and not fiddle with the micro electronics etc - for example if you have come from 5 inch racing or freestyle quads.

The Emax BabyHawk R is currently available from Gearbest with or without receiver. The model without receiver is $166. If I get access to any specials I'll post on my coupons ans discounts page.
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Flight videos

​...to follow
2 Comments

    Quick Access Menu

    All
    1103
    1104
    1105
    1106
    1204
    120rs
    1505
    20mm
    2207.5
    2508
    2.5 Inch
    2 Inch
    2s Whoop
    3 Inch
    4s Micro
    5 Inch
    6s
    7500kv
    7 Inch
    Action Cam
    Adapter
    AIO
    AirA
    Antenna
    Aomway Commander
    Ascent
    Asteroid
    Babyhawk R
    Battery
    Beebee 66
    Beeper
    Bench Review
    BNF
    Boldclash
    Bolt
    Brushless Whoop
    Budget
    Build
    Canopy
    Charging
    Christmas
    Cinewhoop
    Cloud 149
    CM275T
    Cobra
    Comet
    Crossfire
    Crux3
    Diatone
    Drone
    Dvr
    DYS
    Eachine
    Eachine Cvatar Cinewhoop
    Eachine Shadow Fiend
    Eachine Tyro79
    Eachine Vrd3
    Emax
    ESC
    F02h
    F3
    Fatshark
    Fatshark Attitude V5
    First Flight
    FlexRC
    Flight Controller
    Flyfox 110
    Fpv
    Frame
    Freestyle
    FRSKY
    FRSKY X-lite
    Ft5
    Full Speed
    FUS Spartan
    FUS X111 Pro
    Gemfan 2540
    Goggles
    Goggle Strap
    Happymodel
    Hawk 5
    Hawkeye Firefly 2
    HB64
    HD Footage
    HGLRC
    Hobbycool
    HobbyCool.com
    Iflight
    Isdt
    JHEMCU
    Jr Port
    Jumper T8SG
    Komori
    Lal5
    Larva-x
    Leader 120
    Leader 2.5
    Leader 3
    LED
    Long Range
    LST S2
    Micro Quad
    Mobula
    Mobula7
    Motors
    Namelessrc
    Novice-i
    Oled
    ORT Dual Shield
    PIDs
    Pnp
    Portable
    Propellers
    R249+
    Racerstar
    Radiomaster TX16s
    Ready To Fly
    Red Devil
    Review
    Roma F4
    Roma F5
    Runcam
    Runcam 5
    Rush
    Sailfly X
    Sailfly-x
    Shootout
    SKY03O
    Skystars
    Skyzone
    Smart Audio
    Snapper7
    Sweet Spot
    Taranis
    TBS Tango2
    Tinyleader
    Tiny Tank
    Tmotor
    T-motor
    Toothpick
    Toothpick Pro
    TP3
    Transmitter
    Trashcan
    Tutorial
    Twig
    TX01
    Upgrade
    V1s
    Vtx
    Whoop
    X120
    X Lite
    X-lite
    ZJWRC 115X

Thanks for visiting QuadifyRC.com Follow us on facebook below to get all the latest updates
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact