QUADIFYRC MODS AND REVIEWS
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact

QUADIFYRC Quadcopter reviews

Aomway Commander V1s: review and comparison to the v1

19/6/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Aomway Commander V1s is a new binocular FPV goggle released by Aomway, a follow up to the very successful V1. Below I look at how these two compare and what the new V1s is like in it's own right.
Introduction
As much as we spend time looking at our quadcopter builds, it's the goggles that link us visually to a quadcopter (or anything FPV for that matter) and so are commonly the spot where we spend the most. Aomway released the Commander V1 in 2017 and they have been my firm favourite since then and I wrote about my experience in my review.

Many similar looking binocular goggles have been released since then in a similar price bracket but there have been more misses than hits with goggles like the topsky being firmly in the 'miss' column. Even Aomway itself released a version 2 that had a larger field of view and better antennas but unfortunately had poor lenses and a high price tag meaning it never reached the same level of success as the V1. In fact it is no longer available for sale...

In this time the Commander V1 has steadily gone about its business and racked up sales and has many happy customers and so Aomway have updated the V1 to the V1s rather than basing development off the V2
What has changed compared to the V1?
Very little has changed! The Aomway Commander V1s is a very minor upgrade to the V1 and for the purposes of comparison here are the difference of the between the 2 as quoted in an email from Sean @ Aomway:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Same accessories (battery cable from the V1 is present but not in shot
Not mentioned here is also the fact that the number of channels that can be received has been expanded from 48 to 64, This is not a whole lot of use because the extra 24 channels are largely illegal to transmit on in most countries. There is talk that the received may have also been "improved" but this is not the case. There were also rumours that DVR has been improved to 60fps (which would have been an awesome feature) but this is also not the case. Speaking of case, the case is larger than the V1 - now you can fit the goggles, battery and antennas rather than just the goggle unit themselves
Picture
New case has room to fit goggles and accessories
Picture
Old case barely has enough room to fit the goggles and certainly no more
Quite simply if you are looking to upgrade your Aomway Commander V1 to these, don't. These new 'features' are so minor as to say there is no difference at all.

If however you are looking at upgrading from something else or purchasing these as your first pair then read on - even with no real upgrades they are a compelling buy, especially if you can get on discount.
Review of the Aomway Commander V1s
Since they are so similar to the V1 I'll base my review on these since I have been using them several times a week for nearly 2 years and I feel I am in an extremely strong position to be able to talk all the benefits and challenges.
What's included?
  • ​1 x AOMWAY Commander V1S FPV Goggles 854x480 64CH 5.8Ghz Diversity RF 2D/3D 720P HD Input AV-IN/OUT Built-in DVR Support Head Tracker: The goggles
  • 1 x Carry Case: Good size that fit goggles and accessories
  • 1 x AV cable: Sure if you want to plug in ground station
  • 1 x JR cable: No idea what this refers to. Is it even there? Update: Nope
  • 1 x cable: ???
  • 1 x Filtered adapter; Allows you to connect 2s/3s/4s battery
  • 2 x Foam (thin and thick): Comfortable but not long lasting
  • 1 x User manual: Also here in electronic form
  • 2 x Antenna: Excellent cloverleaf omni and horrible patch directional. More on this below.
Picture
Build quality
Before you even turn them on the build quality feels solid and 2 years of field testing confirms this too - no breaks from me on any structural or electrical compnent. The original commanders are grey which is a practical colour since they don't heat up in the sun. Although they look nice the new V1s black goggles will heat up more as a result. Strap feels flimsy but works fine - more on this later.
Screens and optics
The Aomway Commander V1s runs 854 x 480 screen resolution 32° field of view (FOV). Image format is 16:9 and IPD adjustment is 59-69mm

Resolution is good considering we are dealing with a PAL or NTSC signal.

FOV is low on paper but in use is a really nice size. Firstly it is very crisp with no blurring at the edges which is typical with practically every binocular screen 35° FOV and up (Commander V2 included). Even after coming from 5" box goggles this screen does not feel small and I like that my eyeballs are not needing to move during flying - I can focus in one area only for flight. Optics by way of screen clarity are good - there is absolutely no edge blurring meaning no matter where you have your OSD located it can be read clearly.

16:9 format can be switched to 4:3 but this does involve cropping so I recommend 16:9. It sounds odd but I actually prefer 16:9 screens with a 4:3 cam with the stretch it provides compared with running 4:3 on a 4:3 screen. Not sure if it's because I'm used to 16:9 screens on my monitor and TV but I certainly don't see this as a downside. There is no screen cropping on 16:9 either meaning you can see your OSD right around the edges.
Picture
IPD adjustment is 59-69mm and feels like a similar range to the previous model (I'm somewhere in the middle) but the adjustment feels more secure and less like I need to move every time I put the goggles on. I think this is the improvement Aomway speaks of.
Lastly on the optics there are slots for corrective diopters here if needed. Basic prescriptions are available here.
Picture
These diopters will slot in to your goggles if you have a -2 or -4 prescription
Diversity Video Receiver
Since we've already covered the receiver differences in the first section (which are minimal) how does it actually perform? Good enough with decent antennas. Included are the Aomway cloverleaf RHCP antenna and a patch antenna. Without mincing words the cloverleaf is a tried and true good robust performance and the patch is simply awful. Do yourself a favour and pick up another cloverleaf mounted perpendicularly if you fly around yourself or a simple patch antenna to partener with the included cloverleaf if you fly in front of yourself. The RealAcc patch antenna I reviewed here some time ago for example is only $8 and makes a noticeable improvement. Now armed with 2 decent antennas the recevier works well - not great but certainly good enough for me. I even fly 1 km out with the right antennas which largely makes my clearview ground station redundant (I must get round to selling it). The built in goggle OSD shows you which antenna (left or right) has the strongest signal but not RSSI numerically.
Picture
The Aomway cloverleaf is a well regarded durable CP antenna. Extras available here
Picture
This patch is awful. Bin it and get something better, another cloverleaf is good for flying around yourself.
Ease of use
All goggles have a learning curve especially when they are as well featured as the commanders. Now that I've been using them a while navigation is simple and intuitive but in fairness it did take some time to learn.

Channel/band button will allow you to cycle channels with a quick tap, bands with a medium press and autoscan with a long press. Autoscan works well enough but I'd never rely on this for flight, especially now we know exactly which channel we are on with control via betaflight OSD.

Mode button. Depressing the button will cycle you through inputs (AV/HDMI/RF receiver in 2d and 3d formats) but I've never used them. Day to day I use this for rapid contrast and brightness adjustments: up/down and left/right respectively. This is really useful and fast for when lighting conditions change.
Picture
Picture
HT/Fan button is really just used to turn the fan on. This runs the fan for 10 minutes to demist and then shuts off. Waaaay better than the Fatshark bodge-job on their fan. The fan works very well even on the hot, humid summer days.

DVR control. Without going into full detail this allows you to turn DVR on (and record) and also gives you playback control. Playback takes a little getting used to but is an invaluable tool to help you find crash locations. Full instructions are here.

Menu system. The menu system is very basic, the best feature is the ability to set the DVR to autostart when power is applied which I ALWAYS use - I otherwise forget to record. Also here is the DVR playback menu and that is really about it.

Otherwise there is an easy to use micro SD card slot, 3.5mm jack for audio (if your VTX transmits audio like the AKK range), AV in/out via a different 3.5mm jack, mini HDMI in, headtracker module input and IPD adjustment.
DVR
The DVR unit is the same one that is used for every other set of goggles around. Same resultion, bitrate etc. In use the DVR quality is poor when diversity switches between antennae but good when it locks on to one. Check out my youtube channel. Everything on there is from the Aomway commander DVR.
Straps, Foam
The standard strap goes around the back of your head as well as over the top. It's comfortable enough but I don't like it because it feels inconvenient and unecessary especially given how light the goggles are. As a cheap replacement I use the $2 ev100 strap as below. It's easy to put on and has been fine as a replacement
Picture
I don't like the stock strap. The foam is comfortable but it's worth holding on to spares as it is a wear item
Picture
The $2 replacement strap I recommend
Picture
Replacement foam
The foam works well enough but doesn't last long. I'd recommend getting replacement foam - they are cheap so I always keep a few and replace every 6 months or so. I found the goggles and foam to be comfortable against my face and had no light leakage until the foam wore out.
Battery
No battery is included but a very useful 2s/3s/4s to barrel connector plug is. This means you can use any 2s to 4s lipo pack to power the goggles. This can then be attached to the back of the strap or better yet get a barrel connector extension cable like and put a larger pack in your pocket rather than strapped to your head.
Support
We hear a lot about how Fatshark has legendary support even after years of ownership which is great if you live near a service centre. As mentioned above though I've never needed my Commanders to be repaired in the 2 years I've owned them. What few people understand though is that if you have the right contact, Aomway are VERY quick to react and will supply replacement parts at low cost or free of charge. If you need support, contact Sean@Aomway.com
Summary and my recommendation against competitive products
Like any goggle the Aomway Commander V1s is not perfect. The included patch antenna is awful, the strap is awkward, the foam is not very durable and there are not a lot of menu options. The good news is none of these are deal-breakers and they are really good where it counts - Good video signal when the antenna is upgraded, lovely crisp and clear screens, compact design, easy to use features and very importantly, they are durable. After 2 years of using ONLY the Aomway Commander V1, I have not had a single malfunction or damaged part other than replacing the face foam and strap (as a matter or preference). As made painfully clear the new for 2019 V1s is for all intents and purposes the same as the V1 and a return to the formula that has been so popular rather than the V2 which missed the mark a little. The Commander V1s and by extension V1 (which is still for sale at time of writing) are a reliable goggle where you know what you are going to get. Is this enough though in the fast moving world of FPV? Right now the answer is probably yes since nothing groundbreaking has really been launched in this price range although the exact choice probably comes down to feature preference rather than a killer feature. I have noted comparisons to key competitors below:
Picture
Skyzone SKY02C
Perhaps the main direct competition to the Commander V1s. Slightly smaller FOV but similar crisp image. Less available channels than the V1s but this does include a handy spectrum analyser to give you a feel for 5.8GHz noise floor in choosing the most suitable channel for the environment. Pricing is very similar.
Picture
Eachine EV200d
More heavily featured with quad diversity and much larger field of view (42°) but image quality suffers at this size due to the optics used even though the resolution is higher at 1280x720. Includes a battery. Even more channels than the v1s (72!) and a wider IPD adjustment (56-72mm) About $30 more at the time of writing, I'd only recommend these if you really want the larger FOV.
Picture
Fatshark Attitude V5
Not released to the general public at the moment although I do have some on pre-order. Killer feature must be the OLED screens at a similar 32° FOV. The however come at the cost of lack of OSD, poor SD card placement, terrible fan control. 18650 battery box makes good sense even though you'll need to be able to supply your own cells. Another key feature is the ability to upgrade the module. About $40 more expensive at the time of writing.
Picture
Aomway Commander V1
Why are these included on the list? For now these are still available and other than the protective case that is too small to be used, they are practically the same as the V1s. My recommendation would be to buy these if you can get a good discount while they are being run out.
I have a day job where I am well looked after so don't need you patreon money nor your deposits to my bitcoin or paypal accounts. I recommend you keep that money for yourself and your family. I do use affiliate links at no cost to you to help fund the parts I need for articles like this - tips, tricks, ugrades and reviews. If you like this or other articles I've written please click on these product links to help me keep this going. Click on the links below to like or share on facebook and spread the word. Thanks :)
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Quick Access Menu

    All
    1103
    1104
    1105
    1106
    1204
    120rs
    1505
    20mm
    2207.5
    2508
    2.5 Inch
    2 Inch
    2s Whoop
    3 Inch
    4s Micro
    5 Inch
    6s
    7500kv
    7 Inch
    Action Cam
    Adapter
    AIO
    AirA
    Antenna
    Aomway Commander
    Ascent
    Asteroid
    Babyhawk R
    Battery
    Beebee 66
    Beeper
    Bench Review
    BNF
    Boldclash
    Bolt
    Brushless Whoop
    Budget
    Build
    Canopy
    Charging
    Christmas
    Cinewhoop
    Cloud 149
    CM275T
    Cobra
    Comet
    Crossfire
    Crux3
    Diatone
    Drone
    Dvr
    DYS
    Eachine
    Eachine Cvatar Cinewhoop
    Eachine Shadow Fiend
    Eachine Tyro79
    Eachine Vrd3
    Emax
    ESC
    F02h
    F3
    Fatshark
    Fatshark Attitude V5
    First Flight
    FlexRC
    Flight Controller
    Flyfox 110
    Fpv
    Frame
    Freestyle
    FRSKY
    FRSKY X-lite
    Ft5
    Full Speed
    FUS Spartan
    FUS X111 Pro
    Gemfan 2540
    Goggles
    Goggle Strap
    Happymodel
    Hawk 5
    Hawkeye Firefly 2
    HB64
    HD Footage
    HGLRC
    Hobbycool
    HobbyCool.com
    Iflight
    Isdt
    JHEMCU
    Jr Port
    Jumper T8SG
    Komori
    Lal5
    Larva-x
    Leader 120
    Leader 2.5
    Leader 3
    LED
    Long Range
    LST S2
    Micro Quad
    Mobula
    Mobula7
    Motors
    Namelessrc
    Novice-i
    Oled
    ORT Dual Shield
    PIDs
    Pnp
    Portable
    Propellers
    R249+
    Racerstar
    Radiomaster TX16s
    Ready To Fly
    Red Devil
    Review
    Roma F4
    Roma F5
    Runcam
    Runcam 5
    Rush
    Sailfly X
    Sailfly-x
    Shootout
    SKY03O
    Skystars
    Skyzone
    Smart Audio
    Snapper7
    Sweet Spot
    Taranis
    TBS Tango2
    Tinyleader
    Tiny Tank
    Tmotor
    T-motor
    Toothpick
    Toothpick Pro
    TP3
    Transmitter
    Trashcan
    Tutorial
    Twig
    TX01
    Upgrade
    V1s
    Vtx
    Whoop
    X120
    X Lite
    X-lite
    ZJWRC 115X

Thanks for visiting QuadifyRC.com Follow us on facebook below to get all the latest updates
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact