QUADIFYRC MODS AND REVIEWS
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact

QUADIFYRC RC Car Review and Upgrade Guides

Brushless Motor Theory: Adjust ESC timing to control power and heat

20/4/2021

14 Comments

 
My recent guide on upgrading the 144001, 124018 and 124019 with a drop in 2445 5400kv made for a very fast car but also generated a lot of heat for the motor and ESC. In this guide I have a brief look on the impact of adjusting ESC timing on power output as measured by speed and the resulting change in heat of motor and ESC plus efficiency.
Picture
Most cheap ESCs, notably the Surpass/Racerstar are impressive in that there is some basic ability to programme the ESC for throttle punch, dead band, low voltage cut off plus braking and reverse as you can see in this guide. Step up to a more premium ESC like the hobbywing 16BL30 and 10BL120 as recommended in my brushless guide and amongst other items you also have the ability to adjust motor timing.
Basic timing theory
In your internal combustion engined car the motor timing can be adjusted - the point that the sparkplug ignites the fuel in the ignition chamber relative to the piston location. The advance that is applied here compensates for the delay between spark and combustion (related to the octane rating of the fuel). I am oversimplifying things here but advancing timing can benefit power at the cost of efficiency. This relies on engine design fuel, rpm, throttle and other factors so as you can imagine there is no one generic timing ideal.

Much the same is true with your brushless motor but instead of a spark we are talking about the magnetic coil of the motor energising to create a magnetic field to rotate the stator - advancing timing can increase power but typically generating more heat and dropping efficiency. The difference is that this can be managed by ESC programming rather than physical angle adjustment on the motor (although this is true for brushed motors)
So although it is super fast (78kph on 2s), my 2445 5400kv drop in brushless upgrade runs hot and has been known to trigger esc thermal cutout. On any other car I'd look to drop the gear ratio (smaller pinion) but on this car the 15t is already the smallest pinion available. Although cooling solutions like venting, heatsinks and fans can improve I wanted to see if this could be helped with adjusting timing down based on the overly simplified theory that:
Increase timing
  • More peak power
  • More peak RPM
  • More heat
  • Less efficiency
Decrease timing
  • ​Less peak power
  • More torque at lower RPM
  • Less heat
  • ​More efficiency​
Well I have more speed than I know what to do with which means everything in the right column sounds ideal.
How to Decrease Timing
I decreased timing on my Hobbywing 16BL30 using the programming button next to the power switch but if you are not confident counting beeps and LED flashes then the programming card is much easier and not expensive. Note: this is different to the surpass/racerstar one.
Picture
​Hobbywing Quicrun Program Card For RC Car
Picture
Here is the magical programming button on the Hobbywing 16BL30 ESC
If you wish to use the programming instructions the manual can be found here but specially here are the programming details and parameters available for this ESC:
Picture
As you can see it is 11.25 degrees advanced from the factory meaning this is plenty of room to drop (or increase if that is your thing). Because I wanted to see a reasonable impact I went with reducing timing advance to 3.75 degrees. Read on for my results
Results for reducing ESC timing
Definitely slower but still fast - specifically I dropped 10kph top speed going down from 78 kph top speed to 68kph top speed. I didn't pick up on a noticeable increase of torque however punch was kept at the stock setting of 5 with plenty of room to take this up as high as 9 if I want.
Picture
11.25 degrees timing (stock)
Picture
3.75 degrees timing
Good news is that motor and ESC temp have definitely come back. I gave this car a good 10-12 minutes of hard street bashing in a large area meaning decent speed pulls, spinning out and accelerating hard again from standstill. After this the motor and ESC was hot but I could keep my finger on either for more than 3 seconds. At no point did I hit thermal cut off which did tend to be a feature of this setup in my earlier runs at 11.25 degrees advance. The 1800mah 2s battery I was using was just under 3.8v per cell at 12 minutes which is a 10-20% improvement in runtime on the previous setting so this is a nice little gain in efficiency as expected - less energy being wasted as heat.

It is worth noting that the ambient temperature has dropped about 5 degrees from when I ran with stock timing and I am enjoying the additional venting mods that I outlined in my original drop in brushless article. 
Conclusion
Decreasing the esc timing advance from 11.25 degrees to 3.75 degrees has definitely reduced the top speed to a more manageable level with the 2445 5400kv motor but has more importantly reduced motor and ESC temp. The difference is noticeable and was enough for me to have confidence that I would not overheat the motor and not hit ESC thermal cutoff along with the improvements I made to the poorly ventilated 124018. This simple change to programming on this excellent ESC means I can now run my car the way I want it without worrying about damage. I will test other options in the future but for now, this is exactly what I was looking for.

Next up I'll be looking at 2s vs 3s and bringing in a lower speed 3600kv motor to compare.
​Hopefully you have found this article useful, I'm focusing on making my guides and testing more technical and exhaustive so the choice is made easier for you. If you purchase via the links here or on any of my pages I receive a small commission at no cost to you which is enough to help my cover my hosting fees and other expenses related to quadifyrc.com - thanks!
14 Comments
RCFREAK
21/4/2021 03:23:59 am

Very interesting stuff, thanks quad.
I'm running this set up in a 144001 with a short course shell that gives plenty of airflow. I do not think I have hit the thermal cut off yet, but it definitely gets hot. I have run 90% on road, but the 10% off roading definitely put an extra strain on the motor it could perhaps do without. It was almost too hot to touch afterwards and I think because of this I shall keep the 144001 for on road adventures! I have my 124018 to covert into an off road beast 😁😎💪

Reply
QuadifyRC
21/4/2021 08:48:04 am

Nice. If you have the 16BL30 then at least you have the option to adjust if you ever want to further down the track

Reply
RCFREAK
21/4/2021 10:58:50 am

Yes I will definitely play around with it. Since of the settings sound fun, level 9 punch 😉

Have you tried adjusting the timing the opposite way? Do you think on the lowest timing 3s is feasible?

QuadifyRC
4/5/2021 12:28:07 am

Hiya, I haven't done too many other tests with timing as I've been working on motor kV and cell count but the same theory applies for reducing and increasing advance at other increments.

Reply
Ron
23/4/2021 09:30:23 am

I may try this on a slower motor i have with an rpm meter see what they do

Reply
QuadifyRC
23/4/2021 01:47:57 pm

Hey Ron

Before you do, Andrew on the FB group measured wheel RPM with varying timing and found no difference which makes kinda makes sense. Unloaded the motor doesn't care about timing and will should always hit the same peak RPM at max throttle.

This needs to be measured more under load so top speed probably makes more sense. This can be worked back to RPM but yeah, I'm pretty lazy so haven't done this yet 😅

Reply
John
1/5/2021 05:27:32 pm

Hey how do you know if your motor will accept the timing change I have a. Bunch of different motors but I don’t think the timing works

Reply
QuadifyRC
4/5/2021 12:29:48 am

With brushed motors the only timing you can change is on the motor itself. With Brushless systems you have the option of both but ESC is the preferred route as you can control by programming rather than physical/mechanical changes

Reply
Kendu
24/5/2021 08:26:42 pm

As I understand the 10BL120 already has the lower timing?
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0109/9702/files/QuicRun10BL60Sensored.pdf?13464680308998245085

I'm asking because I have the 2445 with 10bl120 and default should be already with lower timing?

Reply
QuadifyRC
26/5/2021 01:41:26 pm

Yes, looks like default timing is zero degrees on that one.

Reply
John
25/5/2021 05:24:17 am

Hobby Wing states that the 10bl120 is not designed for a racing application.

https://www.hobbywingdirect.com/products/quicrun-10bl120-esc?variant=2139725987868

What does that even mean?

Reply
QuadifyRC
26/5/2021 01:42:29 pm

Only thing I can think of is that they have other models with fixed timing for specific classes. I think you can ignore that statement.

Reply
Ian
18/6/2022 06:33:27 am

Does anyone know what the typical timing is for the surpass hobby 35A esc?

Reply
QuadifyRC
29/6/2022 05:40:56 pm

Good question that I can't answer sorry, I've never seen them published.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020

    Categories

    All
    104001
    104002
    104009
    104072
    1/10
    124016
    124017
    124018
    124019
    144001
    144002
    144010
    16886
    16889a Pro
    184016
    284131
    4s
    4 Things
    Anti Roll Bars
    Balance
    Basher
    Battery
    Brushless
    C24
    Charging
    Cogging
    Crawler
    D22
    D32
    Diatone
    Diatone Q25
    Drift
    Drop In
    Dumborc
    Eachine EAT14
    Eachine EC30
    Eachine EC30B
    EMB-MT
    Ex07
    Ex16
    Flyhal
    Flysky FS-G7P
    Flysky Noble Pro
    FMS
    FPV Car
    Goolrc
    Guide
    Gyro
    HBX
    Hbx 901a
    HS10422
    K989
    LC12B1
    LC Racing
    Lipo
    Metal Parts
    Micro
    MJX Hyper Go
    Monster Truck
    Mx-07
    Pinion
    Preview
    Program Card
    Project WLCRacing
    Q33
    Racerstar
    Radiolink RC6GS V3
    RC Boat
    Review
    ROCHobby
    Setup
    Sg 1602
    SG 1603
    SG 1604
    Soldering
    Spectre
    Speed Run
    Stance
    Surpass Hobby
    Timing
    Transmitter
    Tuning
    Tyres
    Upgrade
    Vinyl
    Wheels
    WL916
    Wltoys
    WL Toys
    Wpl
    Zd Racing

    RSS Feed

Thanks for visiting QuadifyRC.com Follow us on facebook below to get all the latest updates
  • RC Cars
  • Car of the Month
  • Quad Reviews
  • Quad Mods
  • COUPONS AND DISCOUNTS
  • Long Range
  • About & Contact